Investor Guide · November 2026
Rent Today or Resale Tomorrow: The Real Difference Between Amtaar, Nawy Shares and Farida

Fractional property apps can look identical on a phone: a photo, a share price and a big percentage. The question that separates them is simpler than any of that. Is this property paying rent today, or am I waiting for someone to buy it later? Amtaar sells shares in finished, leased commercial offices and pays rent every quarter. Nawy Shares sells shares in units still under construction and pays when they are resold. Farida says it offers both rental income and sale profits across a wide mix of property. Amtaar wrote this article, so we have a stake in it. Every statement about another platform comes from its own website or dated press, listed at the end, so you can check it yourself.
Two ways a property can pay you
A property pays in one of two ways: rent while you hold it, or a higher price when it is sold. Rent is recurring and comes from a contract with a tenant. A sale gain arrives once, and its size depends on the market on the day you exit.
A finished, leased office can give you both. A unit under construction can only give you the second, because nobody can rent a building that does not exist yet. That single fact shapes everything else: when you get paid, what you are exposed to, and what happens if the market is weak on the day you need your money.
Commercial and residential are different businesses
Offices are leased to companies, usually on longer contracts. Homes are leased to households, and in Egypt they are mostly bought for their expected rise in price. The gap shows up in the numbers: Mohamed Albostany, head of the New Cairo and New Administrative Capital Developers Association, told Enterprise in June 2026 that administrative units yield 8–10% a year, against 1–3% for residential.
That is why a share in a finished office and a share in an off-plan apartment should not be compared on the same percentage. One number is an income you collect each year. The other is a sale target you collect once, if it is reached.
Amtaar: finished offices, rent every quarter
Amtaar buys completed commercial units from developers including Marakez, Misr Italia, Paragon and LMD, and divides each into shares. You sign a common-ownership contract for that specific unit. Your share of the rent lands in your in-app wallet every quarter, and you can withdraw it to your bank or reinvest it.
The published forecast is a 10% rental yield growing 10% a year, less a 5% management fee on rent, which makes 9.5% net in the first year. On two shares worth EGP 100,000, that is a forecast of about EGP 9,500 in year one, or roughly EGP 2,375 a quarter. There is a one-time 2.5% commission when you buy. These figures are forecasts, not promises.
Now the trade-offs, stated plainly. The minimum is one share, from EGP 50,000, which is higher than other platforms. You can sell only after the first year, through your own buyer at no commission or through Amtaar on the secondary market at 0.5% each from seller and buyer. Rent pauses if a unit is vacant, and a valuation can come in lower.
Nawy Shares: off-plan, paid at resale
Nawy Shares is clear about its model, which deserves credit. Its FAQ says: "All Nawy Shares properties are off-plan, which means they are still under construction and cannot be visited until delivery", and "The current model does not support property rental, as the primary intention is to sell the unit at the delivery date."
So you are paid when the unit is sold: either at delivery, typically around 4–5 years, or earlier if a buyer meets the unit’s target return. Nawy’s own example is a unit with EGP 3 million invested and an 80% target, sold once an offer reaches EGP 5.4 million. Its FAQ also says there is currently no early exit or resale option on the platform, although it can transfer your contract to a buyer you find yourself.
Because most units are bought on instalments, the entry cost is low: instalments start around EGP 5,000 a month. But they are an obligation. Nawy’s FAQ lists an entry fee of 1–3%, a 3% fee on each instalment and a 5% exit fee on the resale value. Three consecutive missed payments can lead to termination, with a penalty. If a unit is unsold at delivery, co-owners stay liable for the remaining payments.
The other side is real too. Nawy lists strong past exits on its site, including net returns above 100% within months when we read it on 4 November 2026. When off-plan prices run, that beats any rental yield. Those are results on units already sold, not a promise for the next one. Nawy has also announced planned funds with CI Capital, with first subscriptions targeted for early 2027 subject to approvals, and reports say they may include income-producing property, so this model could change.
Farida: a wide mix, so ask unit by unit
Farida, run by Sakr Investment Management with Coldwell Banker Egypt, describes returns as coming from "rental income or profits from property sales". Press coverage lists residential, commercial, administrative and medical units, and its partnerships announced in 2026 include serviced apartments and hotel properties, with both existing and under-construction projects under study.
So Farida cannot be summed up as off-plan only or rental only, and it would be wrong for us to say so. What its public homepage does not show is which units are leased today, how much rent they have paid, or when payouts happen. Those answers may exist inside its platform. Get them, for the specific unit, before you put money in.
A fair note on SAFE
Amtaar is not the only rent-paying platform in Egypt. SAFE by Madinet Masr offers commercial and administrative units from EGP 5,000 and pays net rent monthly, with part of its range off-plan. If rent is your goal, SAFE belongs on your shortlist alongside Amtaar. What sets Amtaar apart is the focus: a range made up of leased commercial units, with one contract per unit.
What this means for your money
If you want income now: choose a leased asset. Rent can be spent, reinvested or withdrawn, and it does not depend on the resale market being strong on the day you want out.
If you want maximum growth, can commit to instalments for years and do not need the cash: off-plan can make sense, and the numbers can be much bigger. Accept that the outcome rests on the project, the delivery date and one sale.
If you are unsure: remember these are not rivals for the same job. Many investors could reasonably hold both, sized to what they can afford to leave untouched.
Five questions for any platform
1. Is this exact unit leased today, and can I see who it is leased to and on what terms?
2. How much rent has it actually paid, how often, and where does the money land?
3. If it is under construction, what happens to my instalments if it is late or does not sell?
4. What are all the fees, on entry, on instalments, on rent and on exit?
5. When can I sell, who sets the price, and who decides when the whole unit is sold?
Sources
Nawy Shares FAQ, shares.nawy.com/faqs, and homepage, shares.nawy.com, read 4 November 2026. Farida homepage, farida.estate, read 4 November 2026. Enterprise, 23 June 2026 (yields) and 24 September 2026 (Nawy Shares and CI Capital). Serrari Group on the CI Capital funds. Zawya and Daily News Egypt, 30 November 2025 (Farida and Coldwell Banker). EgyGate News, September 2026 (Farida and Social Brix). Wayak Communications (Farida and Gates Developments). SAFE: investinsafe.com/en/faqs, read 5 October 2026.
Products change quickly, so confirm current terms with each platform before you invest. Amtaar Capital for Financial Investments is licensed by Egypt’s Financial Regulatory Authority to promote and underwrite securities subscriptions. Investing involves risk: returns depend on rent and the property market, and property values can fall as well as rise.
Questions investors ask
Does Nawy Shares pay rental income?
No. Its FAQ says "the current model does not support property rental". Returns come from reselling the unit at delivery or when its target return is met.
What is the difference between Amtaar and Nawy Shares?
Amtaar sells shares in finished, leased commercial offices and pays rent every quarter, and you keep any rise in value. Nawy Shares sells shares in off-plan units, often on instalments, and pays when the unit is resold.
Does Farida pay rent?
Farida says returns can come from rental income or profits from property sales, across a mix of property types. Its public homepage does not publish a payout schedule or which units are leased, so check the specific unit.
Is off-plan better than rental income?
Neither is better for everyone. Off-plan can bring larger gains when prices rise, but pays nothing for years and carries construction and resale risk. Leased property pays while you hold it, usually with smaller headline numbers.
Is Amtaar the only fractional platform paying rent in Egypt?
No. SAFE by Madinet Masr also pays rent, monthly. Compare the unit, the lease, the fees and how you can exit.